21. The passage is primarily concerned with ______.
C
[考点] 主旨的理解
[解析] 1.做题分析
①Until recently, many anthropologists assumed that the environment of what is now the Southwestern United States shaped the social history and culture of the region's indigenous peoples. ②Building on this assumption, archaeologists asserted that adverse environmental conditions and droughts were responsible for the disappearances and migrations of southwestern populations from many sites they once inhabited.
③However, such deterministic arguments fail to acknowledge that local environmental variability in the Southwest makes generalizing about that environment difficult.④To examine the relationship between environmental variation and sociocultural change in the Western Pueblo region of central Arizona, which indigenous tribes have occupied continuously for at least 800 years, a research team recently reconstructed the climatic, vegetational, and erosional cycles of past centuries. ⑤The researchers found it impossible to provide a single, generally applicable characterization of environmental conditions for the region.⑥Rather, they found that local areas experienced different patterns of rainfall, wind, and erosion, and that such conditions had prevailed in the Southwest for the last 1,400 years.⑦Rainfall, for example, varied within and between local valley systems, so that even adjacent agricultural fields can produce significantly different yields.
⑧The researchers characterized episodes of variation in southwestern environments by frequency: low-frequency environmental processes occur in cycles longer than one human generation, which generally is considered to last about 25 years, and high-frequency processes have shorter cycles.⑨The researchers pointed out that low-frequency processes, such as fluctuations in stream flow and groundwater levels, would not usually be apparent to human populations.⑩In contrast, high-frequency fluctuations such as seasonal temperature variations are observable and somewhat predictable, so that groups could have adapted their behaviors accordingly.⑪When the researchers compared sequences of sociocultural change in the Western Pueblo region with episodes of low- and high-frequency environmental variation, however, they found no simple correlation between environmental process and sociocultural change or persistence.
⑫Although early Pueblo peoples did protect themselves against environmental risk and uncertainty, they responded variously on different occasions to similar patterns of high-frequency climatic and environmental change.⑬The researchers identified seven major adaptive responses, including increased mobility, relocation of permanent settlements, changes in subsistence foods, and reliance on trade with other groups.⑭These findings suggest that groups' adaptive choices depended on cultural and social as well as environmental factors and were flexible strategies rather than uncomplicated reactions to environmental change. ⑮Environmental conditions mattered, but they were rarely, if ever, sufficient to account for sociocultural persistence and change.⑯Group size and composition, culture, contact with other groups, and individual choices and actions were—barring catastrophes such as floods or earthquakes—more significant for a population's survival than were climate and environment.
2.文章结构
这是一篇典型的新旧观点类型的文章。由第一句的many anthropologists assumed可以知道,第一段是旧观点。文章后面很可能会反驳这个观点,同时提出新观点。
3.文章精析
第一段:提出旧观点,认为环境是影响一个地区居民生存的重要因素。
①提出旧观点,认为环境是一个影响美国西南部历史(history)、文化(culture)和当地居民(indigenous peoples)的重要因素。
②细节,略读。上一句是抽象的,这一句是具体的。this assumption指的是上一句话的结论,所以考古学家认为恶劣的环境(adverse environmental conditions)造成了美国西南部居民的消失和迁徙(disappearances and migrations),这句话里有一个常见的表达方式:A is responsible for B,即A是B的原因。
第二段:这一段主要讲上述理论的一个问题,即忽略了环境问题的多变性,并以频率为分类标准讨论了不同环境条件的影响。也就是开始反驳旧观点。
③出现取反词However,开始反驳上面的旧观点。这句话是本段的主题句。这个句子的主干是:such deterministic arguments fail to acknowledge that...,大意是旧观点没有考虑环境的多变性(local environmental variability)导致概括环境的影响变得困难这个问题。
④没有取反词,这句话是细节。为了检验Pueblo西部的环境因素(environmental variation)和社会文化变化(sociocultural change)的关系,科学家对于这个问题进行了研究。这句话有两个部分需要略读:(1)which部分属于插入语,修饰Arizona,属于细节的细节;(2)后半句climatic,vegetational,and erosional cycles都是environmental variation的具体例子,可以不用一一理解。
⑤没有取反词,这句话是细节,大意是这些研究发现,对于当地的环境条件很难用简单的概括性特征去描述。这证明了上一句提到的environmental variation。
⑥Rather可以理解为递进。Rather前后两句话往往是一个意思的。当然,Rather一词的意思是:更确切地说;还不如说;相反。You use rather when you are correcting something that you have just said, especially when you are describing a particular situation after saying what it is not.例如:Twenty million years ago, Idaho was not the arid place it is now. Rather, it was warm and damp,populated by dense primordial forest. 2000万年前,爱达荷州并不像现在这样干旱。相反,那时的爱达荷州温暖潮湿,有大片的原始森林。
⑦没有取反词,这句话是细节,这里以降雨为例论证上述观点。插入语补充说明降雨形式视山谷形貌的不同而不同,所以即便是相邻的(adjacent)农田产量也可能不同。其中农田产量也是sociocultural change的一个具体方面。
第三段:这段具体讲科学家的研究,他们把环境问题分成经常发生的和不经常发生的,并且分别阐述了它们对当地社会的影响。大家要明白,这些都是用来反驳旧观点的方法或者手段。
⑧这句话是本段主旨,研究者们按照发生频率把环境变化分类(characterized by frequency),冒号表示解释说明,后面的内容属于细节,详细说明哪些是高频事件或低频事件:低频事件发生的周期长于一代人的时间,通常为25年;高频事件发生的周期要短一些,也就是小于25年。
⑨没有取反词,这句话是细节,说明了研究结果。对于低频事件,such as后面是细节,要对具体例子出现的位置有印象:例如溪水和地下水的涨落,对于居民的影响不会很明显(not usually be apparent)。
⑩In contrast表示对比,说明这句话描述的是高频事件。对于像每个季节中温度的变化(seasonal temperature variations)这样经常发生的事,它们的影响相对显著(observable)而且可以预测,所以当地居民(groups,是上一句human populations的同义替换)会根据这些事件调整自己的行为(adapted their behaviors accordingly)。
⑪虽然句子中有取反词however,但是这句话是细节。当科学家对比社会变迁和环境变化时,他们这两者的关系并不简单(no simple correlation)。这里however是事件之中的转折,而不是提出新的内容:前文主要说科学家发现社会变迁和环境变化是有关系的,后文说这种关系并没有那么简单。
第四段:这一段主要写科学家对Pueblo居民对环境变化的适应情况的发现以及由此延伸出的结论,也就是提出了新观点。
⑫Although强调的是后半句,本身所在的部分为细节:不同情形下,Pueblo居民对于相似的高频环境变化反应也不同,重点是responded variously。细节精读:Although部分对应的是第一段的disappearances and migrations:虽然Pueblo居民没有避开环境带来问题(risk and uncertainty简单理解即可)。
⑬没有取反词,这句话是细节。研究者发现了七种主要的适应方式(adaptive responses),包括增加流动性(increased mobility,也就是migrations),搬家(relocation,也是一种migrations),改变食物以及和别人贸易(trade)。
⑭没有取反词,这句话是细节。These findings指的是上文科学家的发现,这句话的从句比较长,并列关系很多,它的主干是A were B rather than C:A是B而不是C,其中B和C很好理解:B是flexible strategies:灵活的策略;C是uncomplicated reactions to environmental change:针对环境做出的简单的反应;A比较复杂,主体是groups' adaptive choices,是adaptive responses的同义替换,depended on是补充信息,是上文的重复,即这些针对文化(cultural)、社会(social)和环境因素(environmental factors)做出的反应。
⑮没有取反词,这句话是细节。(虽然)环境因素会发挥作用(mattered),但是只有它们并不足以解释(rarely sufficient)社会文化的存在和变迁(sociocultural persistence and change)。
⑯没有取反词,提出新观点。这里列举了其他影响因素,不必一一理解,两个破折号之间是补充信息,是细节,但是这里出现了一个重点词barring:除了,所以这里说的是不包括自然灾害(catastrophes)的环境因素。这句话的主干是其他因素比环境因素更能影响到一个地区居民的生存(population's survival)。所以整篇文章的写作目的达到了,就是用来反驳旧观点。然后得出了新观点:比起气候和环境,这些因素,例如group size and composition, culture, contact with other groups, and individual choices and actions等更加显著。
题型:主旨题
文章的讨论主题是环境因素对社会的影响,行文思路如下:环境影响很重要一实际的环境影响很复杂—环境影响没有其他因素重要,是一个逐步否定第一段观点再提出另一个观点的过程。所有选项中C选项中的challenge an explanation(否定第一个观点)和offering an alternative explanation(提出新观点)最接近理想的答案。答案是C。大家思考一下,为什么是explanation,什么情况下用explanation这个词。笔者的理解是,explanation表示因果逻辑关系,原文里旧观点其实也存在因果逻辑关系:环境决定/塑造了当地的文化和历史。这篇文章探讨的其实就是,到底是什么决定/塑造/导致了当地的文化和历史。文章最后给了explanation (group size and composition, culture, contact with other groups, and individual choices and actions)。